Three Years after Construction, Alternative Planting and Management

Three Years after Construction, Alternative Planting and Management

Three Years after Construction, Alternative Planting
and Management Strategies in Experimental Marshes Induce
Differences in Biodiversity and Heterogeneity, but not in Function
Jake J. Grossman & John E. Petersen,
Oberlin College Environmental Studies & Biology
[email protected]

Background and Objectives

3. Spatial Analysis: In 04-07 photographs were taken weekly during the
growing season at the corner of each cell from atop a 3 m ladder. In 06
and 07, aerial photographs were taken using a camera suspended from a

Two key goals for wetland restoration in agricultural landscapes are to create
biodiverse habitat and to cultivate desirable ecological functions such as nutrient
retention. Wetland restoration practices vary considerably with respect to plant
species management. The goal of our ongoing research is to assess the effects of
management practices on ecosystem structure and function.

2. Water Quality:

No clear differences among treatment are evident in any measures of water
quality. Dissolved inorganic phosphorus concentrations have remained low
throughout (<0.04 mg/L). Ammonium is rarely detectable. Mean nitrate + nitrite among cells '05 to 07 5 4 5 NO2,3 (mg/L) Experimental System & Management In the summer of 03 we constructed and planted six hydrologically isolated ha wetland cells on marginal farmland in NE Ohio owned by Oberlin College. 0.15 0.10 0.05 0 Cells were assigned to one of three treatment groups based on plant species management. High-intensity cells (2&5) and low-intensity cells (3&6) were seeded with 12 native species and planted with propagules of 11 species. The high intensity cells received multiple re-plantings of propagules in subsequent years. Selfdesigning cells (1&4) were not planted or seeded. Cattails (Typha angustifolia and latifolia) and reed canary grass (Phalaris arundinacea) were controlled in all cells. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Geo-referenced aerial photographs of a self-designing treatment (left) and a high-intensity treatment (middle) taken in August of 06. The photograph of the high intensity treatment has been converted (right) to species polygons (green = Nymphaea odorata, blue = Sparganium americanum, purple = Juncus effusus, yellow = Echinochloa crus-galli, blue = Sagittaria latifolia, orange = other wetland species, black = open water). Average nitrate concentrations are consistently low (<0.2 mg/L), but exhibit a regular seasonal decrease from spring to late summer. (Error bars in graph above are standard deviations in concentration calculated among all six cells). Thus far, environmental factors common to all of the cells appear to be a stronger determinant of biogeochemical dynamics than management practices. 3. Spatial Analysis: Species richness 1. Biodiversity: Methods 2. Water Quality Monitoring: During the growing season weekly measures have been made of turbidity, dissolved oxygen, dissolved inorganic nitrogen and dissolved inorganic phosphorus. 1. 2. Literature Cited: Peet RK, TR Wentworth, and PS White. 1998. A flexible, multipurpose method for recording vegetation composition and structure. Castanea 63: 262-274. Smith JL. 2006. The first two years of macrophyte community establishment in six created freshwater marshes undergoing invasive species management. Masters Thesis, Ohio State University. Native species Non-native 20 10 0 1. Biodiversity Surveys: Species diversity and richness and percent cover in each cell have been determined annually using methods adapted from the Ohio EPA (Peet et al., 1998; Smith 2006). 30 High-intensity Low-intensity Planted species, including arrow head (Sagittaria latifolia), water lily (Nymphaea odorata), and bur reed (Sparganium americanum) are major components of the plant communities in planted cells, but not of those in the unplanted cells. We speculate that in spite of their proximity, planted and unplanted cells will remain biologically distinct for decades to come. Spatial heterogeneity appears to be much higher in planted than in unplanted cells. We are in the process of determining the most effective means of quantifying the spatial dynamics of plant community development using a combination of aerial photography, GPS, and GIS analysis. 4. Management: An initial investment of approximately 10 person-hours/cell (40 hrs/ha) in seeding and planting during the first two years was sufficient to initiate development of a robust plant community with significantly higher species diversity and greater spatial heterogeneity than is present in unplanted cells. No clear difference is evident in the invasibility of planted and unplanted treatments. Management effort necessary to control invasive cattails and reed canary grass declined rapidly from over 6 hrs/cell in 2004 to less than 1 hr/cell in 2007. Self-designing Native species richness, Shannon-Weiner diversity, and FQAI diversity are significantly higher in planted than in unplanted cells but do not differ among high and low intensity treatments. Non-native plant richness, like native plant richness, is higher in planted wetlands. (Error bars on graph above are ranges between duplicates in each treatment group). 2005 2006 2007 Late summer Preliminary Findings 2005 2006 2007 Early spring Next steps Our immediate priority is to develop techniques for quantifying spatial patterns in plant community dynamics during ecosystem development. In future years we plan to explore the effect of species diversity on function by simulating agricultural runoff with fertilizer and nutrient additions.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Unit 1 Mix Matter &amp; Flow

    Unit 1 Mix Matter & Flow

    WHMIS stands for … Workplace Hazardous Materials Information System. ... Unit 1 Mix Matter & Flow. Topic 2 - Properties of Fluids & A Whole 'Lotta Science Fun! All pure substances have their own unique set of properties or characteristics...
  • Strategic Planning - Weebly

    Strategic Planning - Weebly

    The Aim can be broken down into a number of objectives SMART Objectives SPECIFIC MEASURABLE ACHIEVABLE REALISTIC TIME RELATED Factors influencing Strategic Planning Stakeholders Business Environment (Legal, Political, Technological) Business Type and Ownership Private Sector Aims Survival Break even Profit...
  • Chapter 1 Making Economic Decisions

    Chapter 1 Making Economic Decisions

    Assign each car will have all 4 tires of a given brand (confounded with differences between cars, drivers, and driving conditions) ... RR. D. C. B. A. 13.2 Principles of Experimental Design. ... The t statistic is of the general...
  • Rol en betekenis van het CPB - - OECD

    Rol en betekenis van het CPB - - OECD

    Arial Wingdings Mathematica1 CPB Corel Presentations 8-tekening CPB: Role and position in policy preparation in the Netherlands Content 'Stylized facts' about CPB Illustrations of CPB's unique position Central Planning Bureau?
  • Colonial America -

    Colonial America -

    Monday, 10/6/14. Come in quickly and quietly, and please have a seat. Write down your homework: On page 27- create a word search or crossword using 10 of the 16 words that are part of our new vocabulary.


    If the same moles of substance were reacted in a larger container of water, would the temperature and enthalpy values stay the same? A: Enthalpy value would stay the same, the temperature however would not go up as much. ......
  • Plant Metabolism Photosynthesis The Most Important Equation in

    Plant Metabolism Photosynthesis The Most Important Equation in

    Extensins help protect or repair damaged cell walls. The plant cell membrane is about 50% structural proteins. Storage Proteins Storage proteins are used mostly in seeds and are used as source of nutrition for the early development of seedlings. Storage...
  • Stoichiometry: Calculations with Chemical Formulas and Equations

    Stoichiometry: Calculations with Chemical Formulas and Equations

    Molar Mass (MM) By definition, a molar mass is the mass of 1 mol of a substance (i.e., g/mol). The molar mass of an element is the mass number for the element that we find on the periodic table. The...