Pathogens Materials: coherence as an operational challenge ...

Pathogens Materials: coherence as an operational challenge ...

Pathogens Materials: coherence as an operational challenge for WHO, the CBD ABS regime and TRIPS Prof. Frederick M. Abbott WTO PUBLIC FORUM 2010 THE (ELUSIVE?) QUEST FOR COHERENCE IN GLOBAL NEGOTIATIONS AND NORMS: THE CASE OF THE TRIPS AGREEMENT AND THE CONVENTION ON BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY (CBD) Organized by International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development (ICTSD) September 17, 2010 The challenge to global governance

Sharing of biological materials with human pathogenic potential is necessary from a public health standpoint for the development of vaccines and therapeutic treatments In some circumstances, e.g., threat of pandemic, prompt sharing critical to avoidance of widespread human suffering and destabilization of global economy and political environment Probability of H5N1 pandemic may be low, but risk to human well-being practically incalculable In other circumstances, e.g., emergence of pathogenic bacteria with limited transmission profile, promptness of sharing a less critical factor, but access to natural biological materials nonetheless essential to R&D

Multilateral institutional response inadequate Multiyear negotiations within IGM-PIP framework at WHO remain stalled, and negotiating texts reflect relatively weak compromise positions on fundamental questions such as sharing obligations Proposals regarding financing to address developing country equity and self-sufficiency concerns are not robust Problems of addressing the common good through stakeholder-based negotiations difficult to overcome Coherence problem emerges at late stage

Biological materials with pathogenic potential appear within technical scope of CBD subject matter (i.e., biological resources) Definitional scope of genetic materials/genetic resources that are subject to access and benefit sharing obligations may exclude viruses due to lack of functional heredity Prior CBD efforts to clarify exclusion of human genetic resources probably irrelevant Problem manifests in ABS Working Group and Protocol negotiations Draft ABS Protocol presents multiple problems of coherence for WHO PIP Working Group

Protocol a separate agreement from CBD Protocol may exclude human genetic resources and/or human pathogens from its scope Protocol may include provision addressing relationship with WHO treatment of pathogens or genetic materials, that may provide for a sharing obligation consistent with future WHO rules But Multiple problems of coherence If human pathogens and/or human genetic resources are excluded from the scope of the Protocol, they would likewise be excluded from the link to WHO rules, and nevertheless would remain subject to the CBD (even if in some cases, i.e.

viruses, excluded from the ABS obligations) How will biological materials with human pathogenic potential be treated by the ABS Protocol and CBD if there is no WHO agreement? Will they be subject to the International Health Regulation? Assuming that two sets of agreements come into effect: will ABS Protocol serve as gap filler for WHO regime? Patent issue coherence WHO treatment of patenting virus genetic resources and derivatives remains unresolved Some possibility for exclusion of patenting unmodified genetic resources, but treatment of derivatives remains contentious

Current ABS Protocol largely relies on national approaches to terms of ABS agreements, but extends obligations for certification of compliance by relevant patent offices Some proposals for application of penalties Assume arguendo completion of WHO PIP agreement and ABS Protocol: WHO solution would apply to pandemic influenza viruses but not to other materials potentially covered by CBD/ABS Scope of parties and WTO United States is not party to CBD and apparently may not be party to ABS Protocol Country with the largest investments in biotechnology sector excluded from arrangements

United States prospectively is party to WHO solution Parties to CBD apparently need not accept Protocol None of the above addresses relationship to Doha negotiations regarding relationship between TRIPS Agreement and CBD Conclusion and suggestion Countries are negotiating toward potential multilateral legal swamp The problem of access to pathogen materials is not likely helped by a legal regime of constructive ambiguity WHO is more logical venue for negotiations on sharing of pathogen materials than CBD, but

developing country voice at WHO not so well empowered, leaving CBD/ABS as attractive alternative Countries should commit the subject of pathogen materials to a single forum and approach with a firm resolve to bridge differences in the interests of global public health, including appropriate interim measures

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • The effects of food on appetite - FEAD

    The effects of food on appetite - FEAD

    Individual characteristics may influence individuals to voice their ideas more or be more persuasive within the group (c.f. Oreg & Sverdlik, 2013) Group Influences on Alcohol-Induced Risk-Taking The Study
  • Finish Batteries Review Capacity  Peukert's Equation o o

    Finish Batteries Review Capacity Peukert's Equation o o

    Modern lithium-ions began using graphite for the anode in about 1997. ... Lead-Acid Can produce up to 500 amps if shorted. 21. Electrical Properties - Charge Density. Alkaline. Much higher than other "off the shelf" battery types. Common cells typically...
  • Social Psych: Interacting with others

    Social Psych: Interacting with others

    1 out of 3 US W will be sexually assaulted in her lifetime US has world's highest rape rate of developed countries (4 X > than Germany, 13 X > than Engl., & 20 X > than Japan. 1 in...
  • Effect of Octyl Salicylate with respect to the physical ...

    Effect of Octyl Salicylate with respect to the physical ...

    Effect of Octyl Salicylate with respect to the physical appearance of mono/di capric and caprylic fatty acids Formulations. 1Siti SalwaAbdGani, 2Majella E Lane, 1Rabiatul AdawiahRamli, 1Mahiran Basri. International Conference on Pharmaceutical Chemistry
  • Présentation PowerPoint

    Présentation PowerPoint

    L'oligoarthrite désigne une atteinte de 2 à 3 articulations. Le terme de polyarthrite, par usage impropre, désigne le plus souvent la polyarthrite rhumatoïde (PR), et est utilisé devant plusieurs atteintes articulaires.
  • Things Fall Apart is a tale grounded in

    Things Fall Apart is a tale grounded in

    New York Herald Tribune Book Review ... Alice Walker reading to family: "paradise regained." ... - Tall and thin with a stoop, face beamed with blessedness and peace (2) - Played the flute, believed in good fair and good fellowship...
  • Deutsche Werde - Community College of Rhode Island

    Deutsche Werde - Community College of Rhode Island

    By Marcal/Joachim Lucas Verardo Some Important Terms Phonology- The study of sound patterns in a language Morphology- The study of word formation of a language Case- Any addition to a noun stem to change its meaning Syntax- General term for...
  • Intro. ToR. Assessing adaptation according to the ToR ...

    Intro. ToR. Assessing adaptation according to the ToR ...

    Oxfam - Outcomes and Learning. Climate Risk Management. Participation through Land Use Planning with district council. Institutional Integration through access to communal land tenure . Note that this is the only case study with use of Communal ownership of land)...